Ga naar de inhoud

Agency vs freelancer vs employee

Written by Pim van der Heide - 23 mei 2023


Pim van der Heide

Chief Content

Get in touch

Agency vs freelancer vs employee: what should I hire for marketing? Pros and cons.

Hiring an agency, freelancer or employee for marketing can be a tough decision. For ambitious companies, this decision could be crucial for impacting the growth and success of the business. Each option comes with its own set of pros and cons. Understanding these can help you make the best decision.

As an agency we are confronted with these types of businesses’ considerations on a daily basis. To help you out, we gathered all of the doubts and wrote you a blog. In this blog, we’ll explore the advantages and disadvantages of each option: hiring an agency, a freelancer or an employee. So, you are able to make the most important business decision for your growth.

Hiring an agency and the pros:

a) Expertise and specialization: an agency often consists of teams with diverse skill sets and expertises. They can offer comprehensive services that cover various aspects of marketing, such as strategy, content creation, social media management, and advertising. This ensures that you have access to a wide range of professionals who can handle different tasks effectively.

b) Established track record and experience: an agency typically has a portfolio of successful campaigns and satisfied clients. Their experience and knowledge in the field can be invaluable when it comes to creating and implementing effective marketing strategies. They can bring you fresh perspectives and innovative ideas to the table, helping your business stand out.

c) Scalability and flexibility: an agency is always equipped to handle projects of different sizes and can scale their resources according to your business’s needs. Whether you require a short-term campaign or long-term support, agencies can adapt and allocate their team accordingly. This flexibility allows you to adjust your marketing efforts as your business grows.

Hiring an agency and the cons:

a) Higher costs: hiring an agency can be more expensive than other options, especially for smaller businesses or entrepreneurs with limited budgets. An agency often charges higher rates due to the expertise, experience and overhead costs associated with running a professional agency. 

b) Lack of personalization: an agency works with multiple clients simultaneously, which means their attention and focus may be divided. While they strive to understand your business and its goals, the level of personalization and attention to detail might not be as high as with other options. 

c) Communication and response time: due to the team-based structure of an agency, communication may sometimes be slower or less direct compared to working with individuals directly. If you prefer immediate feedback or quick response times, it could be a potential drawback when collaborating with an agency.

Hiring a freelancer and the pros:

a) Specialized skills and flexibility: freelancers often possess niche expertise in specific areas of marketing and can provide personalized attention to your project. They tend to be more flexible in terms of availability and can adapt to your changing requirements..

b) Cost-effective solution: freelancers typically charge lower rates than an agency due to their lower overhead costs. This makes them a more affordable option for entrepreneurs like Barry, particularly if they have a limited marketing budget. Freelancers can offer high-quality work at a fraction of the cost, ensuring value for money.

c) Direct communication and collaboration: working with a freelancer allows for more direct and frequent communication. This can result in a closer working relationship, as you can provide feedback and guidance more directly. This level of involvement can contribute to a more personalized and tailored marketing approach.

Hiring a freelancer and the cons:

a) Limited availability and bandwidth: freelancers may have other commitments and projects, which could limit their availability or ability to take on larger-scale campaigns. Mostly, compared to hiring an agency. This might be a concern, especially if you require consistent support or have tight deadlines to meet.

b) Reliance on individual expertise: unlike an agency, freelancers are usually individuals who specialize in specific areas. While this can be advantageous for focused tasks, it may limit their ability to provide a comprehensive marketing strategy. You need to hire multiple freelancers to cover different aspects of his marketing needs, which can add complexity to coordination.

c) Single point of failure: relying on a single freelancer means that if they become unavailable due to unforeseen circumstances or decide to discontinue their services, your marketing efforts may be significantly impacted. This lack of backup resources or redundancy could pose a risk to his business continuity.

Hiring an employee and the pros:

a) Dedicated resource: hiring an employee allows for a dedicated professional who works exclusively for your business. This level of commitment can foster a deep understanding of your business’s goals, values, and target audience. It also ensures more consistent availability and reliable support when compared to an agency or a freelancer.

b) Long-term investment: an employee can become an integral part of your team and contribute to the growth and success of your business in the long run. With proper training and development, they can develop a deep understanding of your industry, products, and customer base. This can lead to more aligned marketing strategies and better results over time.

c) Full control and flexibility: having an in-house marketing professional gives you direct control over the strategies, execution, and timeline of your marketing campaigns. You are able to collaborate closely with your employee, tailoring their activities to align with your vision and goals.

Hiring an employee and the cons:

a) Higher costs and overhead: hiring an employee comes with additional costs beyond their salary, such as benefits, taxes, and office space. For small or growing businesses, these expenses can strain the budget and limit financial flexibility. Therefore, it’s important to consider your overall cost implications of hiring an employee.

b) Limited skill set: an individual employee may not possess the same breadth of skills and expertise as an agency or a team of freelancers. They might be specialized in specific areas, which could limit their ability to handle diverse marketing tasks. This may require additional training or hiring additional staff to compensate for skill gaps.

c) Recruitment and onboarding: finding the right employee for the marketing role can be a time-consuming process. It involves advertising, screening, interviewing, and training, which can delay the implementation of marketing initiatives. That’s why you need to consider the timeline and effort required to hire and onboard an employee.

Agency vs freelancer vs employee

We admit: making the right decision takes courage. Each option offers unique advantages and drawbacks, and the decision ultimately depends on factors such as your budget, desired level of personalization, project scale, and long-term vision. By carefully considering these factors, we are confident that you can make an informed choice that aligns with your aspirations and helps you take your business to new heights of success.

More inspiration?

2 jun 2023

Video marketing: 7 reasons why

branding agency

1 jun 2023

Top 14 questions we get as agency

10 mei 2023

Digital branding checklist

The choice is yours

Let's talk